
Apologies for the bad joke on the title - I was looking forward to this film...I'd seen "Ong Bak" and was impressed by the sheer artistry of no-cgi stunts - yes there's wire work, but its only there as a safety precaution, apparently.
I was drawn to it's story after reading reviews, aside from wanting to see another in your face example of martial arts - this time it's a young girl seeking revenge and pay back for her sick mother, a one time gangsters moll, who is dying of leukaemia.
It's probably wrong to compare films - like most martial arts films, the story is usually the slimmest excuse for the real attraction, but here the films USP is that the lead character has "special needs" and is technically handicapped since birth - this could come across as crass and unsympathetic, but, having a handicapped child of my own, it had special resonance for me.
I was constantly reminded of the Hindi films "Koi Mil Gaya" and its sequel "Krrish" (both, incidentally, hugely popular all over S.E Asia) which had a similar theme behind them - but there after any similarity ends to make way for some truly bone crushing action sequences and a level of brutality (if you like) which almost saves itself by moving into a cartoon-like exaggeration.
It's interesting that all the violence is contextualised by the girls handicap and what might appear totally objectionable, is given a rationale - she even has a face-off with the villains epileptic son in a scene which borders on the comical - in a previous era this scene would have been excised on the grounds of taste, and it does make for uncomfortable viewing.
There is an eye-catching animation sequence in the film at a pivotal point - where the girls motivation is crystallised - & the stylisation of the graphics seems to suggest to the viewer the subjective view of someone mentally challenged, quite effectively.
In total I have to say that the film succeeded in moving me enough that I could almost forgive the level of violence - saved by occassional humour and some rather clever use of CGI which reminded me of the work of the Jeunot brothers ("Delicatessen") - and also the few curiously undynamic scenes which just looked like a girl fighting for her life - ie they seemed to lack the flair & balletic quality present in Ong Bak (also referenced in the film through a film the girl is watching on TV) - but this is all redeemed in a breathtaking climax fought on the sheer walls of a tenement block.
Going by the outtakes and end credits for this film, it seems as if commercial cinema really is a life and death issue in Thailand, at least for the stuntmen involved, and there are moments where you feel you are witnessing something very close to a "snuff movie", which is a worrying development - the level of brutality skims very close to being objectionable and I was left feeling both elated but also rather depressed by the picture of life being presented - so much so that it gave me nightmares afterwards.
The perfect antidote to restore my belief that life is not necessarily so unremittingly grim is the DVD of Jacques Remi's "Umbrellas of Cherbourg", which I bought at the same time - call me a sap, but I'm really not too keen on seeing too many films which feature violence and what seems like a careless disregard for human life, even if its James Bond - and no one can convince me that these films truly reflect modern life in any way, if anything, they seem to be a visualisation of the collective "ID" - a sublimation of anger and angst directed at no one in particular but suggesting a pent up hostility at some unspecified threat - whereas at least in "Chocolate", the girls disability becomes a focus for her behaviour, and that is its one saving grace.